In my last post I was bemoaning my some what irrational urge to build a Moxon vise. Making a fixture or tool if I can is in my opinion always better than buying a new tool unless there are no other options. When I started out I had a very limited amount of money to invest in tools. Luckily, flea markets and garage sales were a great source of inexpensive basic tools. At some point as your skills improve it makes sense to try making your own simple tools and jigs. The worst that can happen is that you fail, and the piece goes into the woodstove. You fail, you try again. That's how we learn.
As much as I think making a new Moxon vise is, for me personaly, a waste of my time, the latest issue of Popular Woodworking had several articles that appealed to me. A marquetry decorated tool box lid is wonderful. My personal marquetry skills are nil. This is the kind of over the top project that proclaims the skill of it's creator, but is beyound the reach of most of us. Note to self: schedule marquetry for my eighth life time. But the raamtang was interesting. So last night I found myself rummaging around in the attic of my shop looking for some white oak. Laugh at self, after complaining about one vise I am considering making a Raamtang. A what???? According to Zachary Dillinger, a raamtang is dutch for window pliers, a fixture used to clamp narrow lengths of window stock for planing. Stupidly, this fixture makes sense to me. It has been at least ten years since I last made window sash by hand. That project involved making multiple window sash for a local historic home which had been damaged in a house fire. Right now I have three Windsor chairs which need to be finish sanded and painted in time for next month's Common Ground CountryFair, and a bench full of molding plane bodies for which I need to grind and fit irons. And with all these projects sitting on the bench, here I am thinking of building another shop fixture. At least I am building the jig, not buying the finished product.
If I can offer a small word of advice, it would be to if at all possible, make as many of your own tools and jigs as possible. Doing so saves both money and improves your skill as a woodworker. Money was my main objection to the Moxon Vise being sold by Lake Erie Toolworks. The vise is a simple project. And, if you buy a tap and die set (they aren't that expensive) you will find yourself using it over and over. Spend your money somewhere else.
I realize that all woodworking magazines have to sell advertizing in order to survive. Every issue is packed with attractive tools and gadgets that according to an ad or indorsement will make you and I better craftsman. So think about the dicotamy between the thinly veiled advertizing in Chris's endorsement of the Moxon vise, and the subject of his book "The Anarchist's Tool-box." The book looked at the number and kinds of tools found in woodworkers'toolboxes over the last three-hundred years using funeral inventories recorded at the death of a craftsman.The take-away from the book is that over this period of time the number of tools owned by most woodworkers grew from about forty tools to sixty. But at all times the number was limited by the need to be portable. The number of tools also tended to be restricted to those most essential to a man's particular craft. Now we have hundreds of products on offer, and in my not so humble opinion most are unnecessary. Which, again, was one of the points of Schwarz's book.
Given my rant on tools and money, what have I spent my money on recently? Well, I slurged on a ForgeMaster single burner propane forge to better heat treat my plane irons. The small forge costs $489.00. Worth it if I can raise the number of hand planes I sell. And then last week I special ordered some extra long brad point bits from the Fuller Company. In drilling out the throat for the wedges in my planes I have found that the jaws of the chuck bump into and marr the top of the plane's stock if I drill too deeply. The extra long bits should solve this issue.
All of this comes down to, make what you can. Buy what you can't make for yourself. Remember that a tool you have made yourself, even if flawed is more valuable in the long run than a shiney store bought thing that looks great on a shelf.
Have a good day.